Key takeaways
- Ask Americans to name a favourite and the best fast food burger is Five Guys, by a hair over Burger King.
- Strip off the bun, the cheese and the sauce, blindfold the tasters, and the answer changes: a grass-fed patty won our test outright, and Burger King beat McDonald's and Wendy's among the chains.
Ask Americans to name a favourite and the best fast food burger is Five Guys, by a hair over Burger King. Strip off the bun, the cheese and the sauce, blindfold the tasters, and the answer changes: a grass-fed patty won our test outright, and Burger King beat McDonald's and Wendy's among the chains. That plain Burger King patty is what Dr. Mike then ate 20 times a day for 30 days.
What is America's best fast food burger?
By popular vote, the best fast food burger is Five Guys. YouGov found 15.5% of Americans named Five Guys as best for burgers, just ahead of Burger King at 15.0%. That is a tie with a press release attached.
Here is the real problem. Nobody in that poll tasted anything. They named a brand. A brand is a memory of a whole meal: the bun, the cheese, the fries, the drive home. It tells you what people like to order. It tells you nothing about the meat.
I wanted to know about the meat, because the meat was all Dr. Mike was going to eat.
How did our blind taste test pick a burger?
We put plain patties from McDonald’s, Wendy’s and Burger King on plates next to a free-range, grass-fed patty, blindfolded the tasters, and let the meat speak. The grass-fed patty won. Burger King won among the chains.
The setup was double-blind. My daughter Athena plated the samples. Chantea placed them at random. I watched, and I did not know which sample was which. Those three chains were the only ones within five miles of us, so that was the field. No bun. No ketchup. No pickles. Just beef and a fork.
The film shows the scores: Burger King got 34 points, the grass-fed burger got 46 points, McDonald’s got 17, and Wendy’s came in at 21.5. My kids still bring up the McDonald’s number at dinner. If you aren’t testing, you’re guessing, and that day we tested the one thing a poll skips.
Why does a favourite poll differ from tasting plain meat?
A poll measures loyalty to a whole sandwich; a blind plain-patty test measures the beef alone. Those are two different questions, and they can give two different answers.
Let me explain. Cheeseburgers are built to taste like their toppings. Sauce carries salt and sugar, cheese carries fat, a soft bun carries sweetness. The book notes a typical chain bun can hold up to 9 grams of sugar. Take all that away and the patty has nowhere to hide.
The film suggests something I believe: most people have never tasted the meat they say they love. In my experience, the first plain bite surprises almost everyone at the table. That is why we cut the bun, and I wrote about it in how this differs from Super Size Me.
What did we never get to measure?
We never lab-tested the patties themselves. I tried. Every lab either refused or quoted a five-figure minimum, so the nutrition inside that Burger King meat was never analysed.
Sit with that for a moment. You can buy those patties by the hundred, but you cannot easily find a lab willing to tell you what is in them. The lab that ran Dr. Mike’s bloodwork refused to be part of the film too, so I paid for the testing myself.
So the taste test picked the burger, and his blood would have to tell us what it did. Here is what we drew and when.
What did 20 plain patties a day do to a fit doctor?
It wore him down, measurably, and the full answer is in the film. The film shows Dr. Mike eating 20 plain Burger King patties a day for 30 days, water only, with bloodwork and fitness tests along the way.
His HRV was cut in half within a week and was only a little over halfway back by Day 19. Dr. Mike wrote of dizzy spells and nausea, and by Day 12 he had lost interest in eating and was setting alarms to remind himself. On Day 29 he called his last fitness test miserable: record-low ARX numbers for him, and his worst mile since maybe middle school.
That is one man. Individual results vary, and what his day-30 labs showed I will not spoil here. That is the entire stakes of the film.
Does this mean grass-fed beef is the answer?
Not automatically. Grass-fed won the taste test, but it did not make Dr. Mike bulletproof. After a keto-pescatarian reset month he recovered; on a later month of grass-finished beef he declined again, though less. The book concludes he does best on vegetation with some fish.
The evidence says the bigger divide may be processing, not the brand: in an inpatient randomised trial, people on ultra-processed food ate about 500 kcal a day more than on unprocessed food, though it ran only two weeks with 20 people.
Cooking it yourself also puts safety in your hands: USDA says to cook ground beef to 160 degrees F. Compare all of this with what the 600-burger experiment tested.
Frequently asked questions
What is the biggest burger at Burger King?
The Triple Whopper is the big one. Chowhound calls it Burger King’s tallest burger, with three beef patties stacked under ketchup, tomato, lettuce, mayonnaise, pickles and onions (https://www.chowhound.com/1909440/fast-food-chains-largest-burgers/). Our experiment went the other way entirely: one plain patty at a time, no toppings, repeated all day.
Who are Five Guys' main competitors?
The usual names are In-N-Out, Shake Shack and Whataburger. Owler lists Whataburger, Shake Shack and Five Guys among In-N-Out’s top competitors (https://www.owler.com/company/in-n-out/competitors). In the popularity poll, though, Five Guys’ closest rival was Burger King, which also happens to be the chain whose plain patty won our blind test.
What's the best way to cook a burger at home?
Use a thermometer, not your eyes. USDA advises against judging ground beef doneness by colour and says to measure 160 degrees F internally (https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and-preparation/meat-fish/color-cooked-ground-beef-it-relates). Beyond that, start with beef you trust and taste it plain once, so you know what the meat brings before the toppings arrive.
Why did Dr. Mike eat Burger King instead of Five Guys?
Five Guys was not one of our options. We tested the only three chains within five miles of where we were based, plain and blindfolded, and Burger King’s patty scored highest of the three. Every burger was bought and eaten, and the project was never an attack on any restaurant.
Can I watch the taste test and the 30 days?
Yes. The Keto Project is on Amazon Prime Video to rent or buy, and it includes the blind taste test, the burger pickups and Dr. Mike’s testing. The prequel book, 600 Burgers in 30 Days, carries his day-by-day journal. Neither one is a plan to copy: the month was done under observation for a film.
The Bottom Line
A poll tells you which logo people love. A blindfold tells you which meat they actually prefer. Ours picked grass-fed first and Burger King second, and that plain Burger King patty became Dr. Mike’s only food for 30 days. What will you do with that the next time you order a favourite you have never tasted plain?
Want to know how his month ended? Watch The Keto Project on Prime Video, or get the book and read his journal day by day. More on the film.
Sources
- America's top fast food joints: Who wins the battle of the burger? (YouGov)
- In-N-Out Competitors and Alternatives (Owler)
- 10 Of The Absolute Biggest Burgers You Can Buy From Fast Food Chains (Chowhound)
- Ground Beef and Food Safety (USDA FSIS)
- Color of Cooked Ground Beef as It Relates to Doneness (USDA FSIS)
- Ultra-Processed Diets Cause Excess Calorie Intake and Weight Gain (Hall et al.)
This article is for information only and is not medical advice. Individual results vary. Speak to a qualified clinician before changing how you eat.
The whole experiment is in the film. 600 burgers, 30 days, every blood test — and the ending we never post.
Watch The Keto Project on Amazon